Let’s start with the obvious: the 2024 Fall Economic Statement should have been a reckoning, a sobering account of failed plans and broken promises, topped off with a bold plan to right the ship. Instead, we got a litany of excuses wrapped in polished PR. The government is playing the “hope the electorate isn’t paying attention” card while the house is burning down. Over the last few weeks, I have reread all the budgets since Trudeau took power looking for promises and themes and in my opinion, this has shed light on proof, that having nice hair and a certain last name, does not equal a good leader.
The $61 Billion Elephant in the Room
Remember when deficits were supposed to be “modest” and “temporary”? Yeah, neither does this government. The 2024 deficit has ballooned to $61.9 billion—an eye-watering $22 billion more than projected just last year. Fiscal anchors? Breached. Promises? Evaporated. It’s like watching someone promise to go on a diet while double-fisting donuts. And yet, the government seems to think they’re nailing it.
Housing: The Great Canadian Mirage
Housing affordability was the crown jewel of promises from Budget 2016 onward. Back then, we were assured that massive investments would make housing accessible for everyone. Fast forward to 2024, and housing prices and rents have doubled. Millennials and Gen Z, the very demographics these budgets claimed to champion, are stuck in rental hell, while homeownership becomes a pipe dream.
This year’s promises to “build more homes faster” feel like watching someone bail water out of the Titanic with a teacup. Sure, they’re doing something, but the ship is still sinking.
Inflation: A “Global Problem,” or Just Poor Management?
The government has been quick to blame global pressures for inflation, but let’s be real: you can’t spend your way out of inflation any more than you can cure a hangover by drinking more tequila. From grocery prices that make a $100 bill feel like Monopoly money to soaring energy costs, Canadians are being squeezed while the government throws cash at half-baked programs that yield little relief.
Remember the “grocery rebate”? That was like handing out umbrellas in a hurricane. Helpful for a moment, but the storm’s still raging.
Crime and Public Safety: The Missing Chapter
Budgets from 2022 onward touted investments in public safety, opioid crisis management, and judicial reforms. Yet here we are in 2024, with crime rates surging and urban centers feeling increasingly unsafe. What happened to all those promises? It’s like ordering an expensive meal and getting an empty plate. The ingredients for success might have been bought, but they were never served.
A Masterclass in Spin
Here’s where the government really excels: presenting failure as progress. The 2024 Fall Economic Statement was a masterclass in selective storytelling. Debt servicing costs are skyrocketing, yet we’re told the debt-to-GDP ratio is manageable—as if future generations won’t be footing the bill. Fiscal responsibility is paraded as a guiding principle, even as deficits deepen and debt balloons.
Unmasking Canada’s Economic Spin: The Truth Behind ‘Net GDP’
Here’s a tidbit no one’s talking about: the Canadian government has quietly shifted to factoring CPP (Canada Pension Plan) and QPP (Quebec Pension Plan) into its calculation of “Net GDP,” conveniently painting a rosier picture of our economic health. But here’s the kicker: as a 2021 study explained, these pension assets—representing one-third of the difference between net and gross debt—are already spoken for. They’re required to meet obligations for existing and future retirees. Touching these assets to offset other government debts is like taking money out of your kid’s college fund to buy a new car—it might solve your short-term problem, but the long-term fallout will be catastrophic.
If we measure gross or total debt as a share of the economy rather than net debt, a very different—and more honest—picture emerges. In 2022, Canada ranked 20th out of 29 OECD countries, with total government debt equaling 111.6% of the economy. Let that sink in: we’re only outperforming fiscal disasters like Greece, Italy, and Japan. What happened to being the responsible grown-up in the room?
Here’s the brutal reality: Canada drops from having the lowest level of government net debt in the G7 to 20th out of 29 OECD countries when we switch to gross debt. And in case you missed it, total government debt in 2022 exceeded the size of the entire Canadian economy by over 10%. That’s not just a red flag; it’s a crimson billboard screaming, “Stop lying to yourselves!”
And yet, in the 2024 Fall Economic Statement, this fiscal sleight of hand is sold as a victory lap. Debt servicing costs are skyrocketing, but we’re assured the debt-to-GDP ratio is “manageable.” Sure, it’s manageable if you ignore that future retirees are footing the bill for today’s delusions. This is where the government excels: presenting failure as progress, gaslighting Canadians into believing we’re fiscally secure while juggling numbers like a bad Vegas magician.
It’s time to call this what it is: a farce. By redefining metrics and rewriting economic narratives, the government is playing a dangerous game of financial chicken with our future. It’s not just misleading—it’s downright irresponsible. The only question now is, how long can we keep pretending the emperor has clothes?
The statement conveniently glosses over the fact that productivity—the Achilles heel of the Canadian economy—remains stagnant. Meanwhile, promises of a green economy and technological innovation are just that: promises. Tangible results? Nowhere to be found.
Broken Promises: A Greatest Hits Collection
Let’s recap some of the greatest hits from past budgets:
- Affordable Housing: Promised to double home construction. Result? Prices and rents doubled instead.
- Childcare Revolution: Sure, fees are down, but availability is still a massive issue. Promises of universal access feel more like a lottery than a guarantee.
- Fiscal Responsibility: Anchors breached, deficits soaring, and public debt hitting unprecedented levels.
- Green Economy: Billions invested, but Canadians are still waiting for measurable outcomes.
This budget should have been a blueprint for righting this ship, but ahoy, I think this will be a job for the PC party when they take over.
The Conservatives’ Inheritance
Here’s the kicker: the hard work of fixing this mess will likely fall to the Conservatives, assuming they take the reins in the next election. Cleaning up this fiscal disaster will require not just tough decisions but a government willing to admit where things went wrong. Spoiler alert: this one isn’t.
What should have been a mea culpa from the Liberals turned into a self-congratulatory pat on the back. A real plan to fix the economy would include slashing unnecessary spending, prioritizing productivity, and addressing the housing crisis with something more substantive than buzzwords. Instead, Canadians are left waiting.
Put a Polish on it!
The Canadian government’s 2024 budget exemplifies the art of presenting fiscal challenges with a polished narrative, often leaving critical readers skeptical. Here are key instances where the budget’s optimistic language contrasts with underlying fiscal realities:
1. Deficit Projections and Fiscal Discipline
The budget forecasts a deficit of $40.0 billion for 2023-24, with slight reductions in subsequent years: $39.8 billion for 2024-25 and $38.9 billion for 2025-26.
While these figures suggest a commitment to fiscal discipline, they represent continued substantial deficits without a clear plan for achieving a balanced budget. The narrative emphasizes responsible spending, yet the persistent deficits indicate ongoing fiscal challenges.
2. Debt-to-GDP Ratio Focus
The government highlights maintaining a declining debt-to-GDP ratio as a fiscal anchor, projecting it to fall from 42.0% in 2023-24 to 41.2% in 2024-25.
This focus on the debt-to-GDP ratio diverts attention from the absolute increase in national debt and rising debt servicing costs, which are projected to reach $54.1 billion in the upcoming year.
3. Capital Gains Tax Increase Framed as Fairness
The budget introduces an increase in the capital gains inclusion rate from 50% to 66.7% for gains exceeding $250,000, targeting the wealthiest Canadians.
While framed as a measure for tax fairness, critics argue it may deter investment and negatively impact economic growth, suggesting the narrative oversimplifies potential economic repercussions.
4. Ambitious Housing Initiatives Amidst Rising Costs
The budget commits to building nearly 4 million new homes to address housing affordability.
However, the feasibility of this target is questionable given current economic constraints and rising construction costs, raising concerns about the practicality of such ambitious promises.
5. Increased Spending Without Clear Revenue Sources
New spending measures totalling $53 billion over five years are introduced to improve affordability for low- and moderate-income Canadians.
The budget lacks detailed plans for revenue generation to support this spending, potentially exacerbating fiscal deficits and national debt, despite narratives suggesting sustainable financial planning.
The 2024 budget employs optimistic language to present fiscal policies, yet a closer examination reveals significant challenges and potential contradictions between the government’s narrative and Canada’s economic realities.
The analysis of government spending reveals significant expenditures on non-crucial projects, with a notable portion of funds being allocated to areas that could be considered unnecessary or outside the immediate needs of Canadian interests. This analysis draws attention to the inefficiency and potential misallocation of resources, raising critical questions about fiscal responsibility and prioritization.
Breakdown of Non-Crucial Expenditures
A detailed examination of the budget has identified several categories of spending that fall under “non-crucial” projects. These categories, often associated with external or non-essential services, include:
| Description | Contract Value (CAD) |
|---|---|
| License/Maintenance fees for application software | 972,824.44 |
| Networking software | 309,765.66 |
| Information technology and telecommunications consultants | 1,073,500.00 |
| Electronic subscriptions and electronic publications | 197,492.23 |
| Research contracts | 508,500.00 |
| Management consulting | 124,300.00 |
Total Non-Crucial Spending: CAD 3,186,382.33
A Hot Steaming Mess
This government is like a contractor who keeps promising your dream home but delivers a cardboard box. Canadians deserve better. They deserve leadership that’s willing to make hard choices, own up to mistakes, and deliver real, measurable progress.
As it stands, the 2024 Fall Economic Statement is a testament to this government’s inability to live up to its own hype. Here’s hoping the next chapter in Canada’s fiscal story is written by someone who knows how to balance ambition with reality.
marksdeepthoughts.ca 
Leave a comment